Top positive review
7 people found this helpful
Just Right for Home Use
By WildBill on Reviewed in the United States on August 31, 2012
I bought these to replace one that looked almost identical that had lasted over 10 years, when they came it was nice to see the change from a chrome looking plastic top to a brushed aluminum, better for finger prints, time will tell on cleaning. Another nice extra is that they have end caps, so any loose pepper after grind does not end up on the counter. Although I am still getting used to it having the cover and have ground a good share of pepper into it, but then you just sprinkle it over the food, no waste, just a duh moment. Of course you do not need to use the caps, so time will tell on that one also. It takes 4 AAA batts and I would strongly suggest Alkiline (common Duracell or Eveready)as the motor needs some good cranking juice, if you use regargables I would go for NiMH, cheap batteries will not fair well, even new. In this model they have a battery retainer ring that hold the 4 batts in place, my old one I used a rubber band to hold them together. OK, now to the real matter at hand, grinding pepper. I was a little worried when I read the reviews about the ability to adjust the grind, and perhaps it is just me but I found it had a pretty good range, from fairly fine, like what you might get in a regular pepper shaker to pretty big, great for salads and grilling. Given my old one had a light on the bottom that was a must have feature, you would not think it would come in handy but it really does, especially on a fine grind onto dark colored food, it lets you see the flow rate very well. These are fairly new, cost a 1/4 of what the other did from Sharper Image, and there are two of them so I have a spare since I rarely have need for fresh ground salt and for that I just use one of those McCormick Grinder/Salt bottles they sell. I used the other one nearly daily for over 10 years. I saw a number of reviews noting a weak motor, and while it is possible to get a bad unit, I did not find the motor weak at all, however if you fill the hopper more than 3/4's full then you can expect trouble, it is not as much the motor being too weak but without room to jiggle around a little too many corns get crammed into the grinder and against the entire case and that is too much for the motot. The other main cause for what appears to be a weak motor are cheap batteries, given that you'll only change batts once a year or so, spring for some good ones, I use Duracell copper tops and they work fine. So, great price, back-up unit if you use it for pepper only, good grind range, bottom light and cap, all makes for a pretty handy unit, and they really do look good also.
Top critical review
6 people found this helpful
not a product i'd recommend now that i've used them for a year....
By michael on Reviewed in the United States on April 4, 2015
UPDATE 12/02/2015 at the bottom: these work ok, but not great. to expand, they tear sea salt up like nobody's business. peppercorn however??? good but not great. if we want fine pepper it simply won't do it. you're going to have to settle for medium or coarse. another thing. either i misread or misunderstood, but i thought i was buying complete stainless steel product. the gears that do all the cracking of the salt/pepper/etc. are plastic. i have no idea how long they'll last, but i wanted a set with stainless guts, and not plastic or cheap pot metal. if the manufacturers were reading this, i'd also add the SERIOUS NEED for a larger hopper for the product. we use ours most every evening and we can't go two weeks without filling them. if the cavity for the salt, etc was twice that large it would be wise... UPDATE 10-18-2015**** i'm still unhappy with the basic design of the grinder. if you can delegate 10" of product height to the product, then toss in another 1" of hopper space to double the capacity. for nearly a year i've been forever filling these up with sea salt and telicherry peppercorns. if people actually use these a lot, they'll probably be unhappy with this relatively low capacity. two major problems. 1, due to the continual need to add product to the hopper the small 'detent' lifts on the cylinder are wearing greatly. they'll be completely worn out soon if you use them quite a bit. both the stainless surround is nearly loose on the plastic fuselage holding the batteries and motor. just like the stainless sheath, the plastic hopper is wearing where it pops into place to lock as well. again, if you use these with meals you'll wear them out quickly. 2, not only do these wear out quickly because you're tearing them down to refill them, but items that are more solid break the plastic gear grinders down. these do fine for the himalayan sea salt that we use, but the telicherry peppercorns are hard, just like any peppercorn, and the gears are now missing a tooth or two. not only am i sure i ingested parts of the plastic gear work, the gears don't grind well. the peppercorns were originally broken down somewhat, but now they are big chunks if anything comes out. all in all this product is below average. i had a person tell me i shouldn't expect so much from a grinder. i reject that soundly. i bought these with the expectations they work. i think them breaking down and wearing out before a year of evening supper service isn't much to ask from the product. what they good for? the wedding gift for some people you don't particular like... do yourself a favor and skip these. UPDATE 12-02-2015 these officially shot craps last night. it's a shame since we did admittedly enjoy them while they worked. however, as i have stated above, they're not much more than an occasional novelty. as a person who engineers and repairs for a living, these simply aren't built to stand up to the burden of routine use. if you're in the mood for an occasional "oh my, these are neat" from your buddies, so be it. if you want them on your kitchen table for daily use, they'll fall apart. i've included pics to help illustrate the issues. you can see in one picture the separation from the see-through hopper to the grinder base. when this falls apart, the entire contents of the hopper fall onto your plate. we had our state senator over for supper and you guessed it - he's the poor guy that the pepper fell apart on and his t-bone steak carved from our own calf was covered in peppercorns. while it made for a great laugh and something to refer to later in conversations, i wasn't amused. another picture depicts the two grinders and the product we used in them. you can see on the left we haven't even managed to burn through a 1KG sack of sea salt. come on... if you can't crush sea salt without falling apart, then you can't call yourself a grinder another pic shows how the base breaks off of the hopper. the red wires exposed WERE attached to a light on the bottom of the grinder. why you need a light to see where the pepper is falling i don't know, but maybe a dark setting could explain that. regardless, the silver tube laying across the base enclosed the wires, but when the base breaks loose, it spins instead of being held affixed in one place. thus, the motor instantly shears off the tube, and winds up the wires pulling them out of the circuit board. the fourth pic shows the silver tube as it sets over the wires just for reference. again, i can't state it enough. nice idea. fun product. nearly no value.
Sort by:
Filter by:
Sorry, no reviews match your current selections.
Try clearing or changing some filters.Show all reviews
Show more reviews