Top positive review
Painful to assemble, but good to contain lightweight clutter
By lfr on Reviewed in the United States on May 5, 2025
Good for light weight items to try to maintain some organization
Top critical review
3 people found this helpful
Product is not as described
By Sheila D on Reviewed in the United States on May 20, 2025
This cubby shelf did not come with a back panel as described in the information when I ordered it. In the description, it states to completely empty the box to ensure the back panel is removed due to it being pressed up against the box on the inside. I emptied the box in its entirety and I can assure you it is not in there. That comment makes me think others have found the back panel not to be in there as well. This is a huge inconvenience. How hard is it to assure all pieces to the product you purchased is in the packaged contents? The back panel is a thin piece of cardboard. If this wasn't so disgraceful, it would be comical. Cardboard? Its actually insulting. This product description would never leave one thinking the back panel is a thin piece of cardboard. Never again!!!
Sort by:
Filter by:
Painful to assemble, but good to contain lightweight clutter
By lfr - Reviewed in the United States on May 5, 2025
Verified Amazon Purchase
Good for light weight items to try to maintain some organization
EASY to Assemble Space Maximizers
By OK - Reviewed in the United States on March 28, 2014
Verified Amazon Purchase
My husband and I bought FOUR of these to help maximize the use of a hall closet that was being used for nothing more than hanging coats. We took the coats OUT, assembled these by stacking them 2 x 2 (two on the bottom, two on the top). They turned out GREAT for their purpose (we're using them for overflow cabinets to keep extra supplements, tea, coffee, etc.). Here are our tips: 1. Use Gorilla Glue as you assemble the outside structure. Makes them much, much stronger. 2. Use a power drill/screw gun, rather than just a screwdriver, to assemble--speeds it up and you'll get a better fit. 3. Make sure the finished edges are facing outward and upward (you'll see what I mean). The unfinished edge is the bottom. 4. Work on a hard floor to get a good, square assembly. Verify everything's "squared" before you nail on the cardboard backing. 5. We glued all parts of the bottom shelves together. On the top shelving units, we DID NOT glue the bottom shelf in place. We DID assemble it and then nailed the backing on the top shelving unit, EXCEPT for the very bottom shelf, which we then removed before stacking the units. Why did we do this? Just to get two "free" shelves, which we were able to install with some extra shelving brackets we had on hand. I'll post a photo in a few days so you can see what I mean (photo posted 4/7/14: see "Customer Images"). 6. Use the dowels provided to "stack." If you want a permanent installation, Gorilla Glue the top unit to the bottom. We did not want a "permanent" installation, so we didn't use glue, The dowels are sufficient to hold the two units in place, as long as you use a bracket to secure the top shelf of the top unit to the back of the closet wall. Works great! Are these strong enough for a child to climb on all the time? No. But if you live in an all-adult household and need some extra storage, these are a wonderful solution. They look GREAT and are very functional. No painting, no mess, no handyman required. You really CAN do it yourself. Highly recommended! UPDATE 4/8/14 CORRECTION: We bought FIVE. We bought ONE more unit, just to use as extra shelves within these organizers. Photo of the finished project has been posted under "Customer Images," just FYI). If you buy extra shelves, you'll need extra shelving pins. These fit ours perfectly: Shelf Pin, Flat Spoon-Style, Brass, 5mm (25). Have a question about these shelving units? Leave a comment & I'll be happy to help you, if I can.
Very nice cabinet.
By Joan Douglass - Reviewed in the United States on April 17, 2025
Verified Amazon Purchase
Very nice cabinet.
Good basic piece
By Michael - Reviewed in the United States on April 17, 2025
Verified Amazon Purchase
Made built-in cabinets with these in my closets. They look like a regular built in at a fraction of the cost.
Product is not as described
By Sheila D - Reviewed in the United States on May 20, 2025
Verified Amazon Purchase
This cubby shelf did not come with a back panel as described in the information when I ordered it. In the description, it states to completely empty the box to ensure the back panel is removed due to it being pressed up against the box on the inside. I emptied the box in its entirety and I can assure you it is not in there. That comment makes me think others have found the back panel not to be in there as well. This is a huge inconvenience. How hard is it to assure all pieces to the product you purchased is in the packaged contents? The back panel is a thin piece of cardboard. If this wasn't so disgraceful, it would be comical. Cardboard? Its actually insulting. This product description would never leave one thinking the back panel is a thin piece of cardboard. Never again!!!
Be warned: Unit may not stack on other or older units of this same model. Some instruction tips, cautions.
By IRG - Reviewed in the United States on May 30, 2013
Verified Amazon Purchase
I have purchased perhaps a half-dozen of these units in the past from various sellers (online and retail). To my knowledge, over the years, ClosetMaid has only offered one model with a thin cardboard paper back (that you nail on) for this 3-shelf model organizer. The various units I have can all be stacked on top of each other using the two insertable wooden dowels that come with it. (There are holes for the dowel on the left and right sides of the top of each unit. You insert the dowels in them and then place the second unit so that the holes on the bottom sides can be placed atop the dowels and pushed down to secure the two sets of organizers.) So imagine my surprise--and dismay--to find out that this unit I purchased specifically to sit atop another unit, does not line up with the other units. By not line up, I mean that the entire unit is something like a 1/8th inch wider in width than the other units so that you cannot get both of the holes on the bottom of the unit to line up with the dowels in the holes on the unit on which you wish to place it. (I had someone else attempt this thinking I maybe just was having trouble doing it myself. But even when we both tried jiggering it, it was a no go.) Now, I don't know if the other units I have are the ones that are "off" by being 1/8th-inch less wide or if it's the new one. This new unit is 12 inches wide as stated. I'm just giving you a heads up to double-check the width of your other existing units if you plan to buy this one and stack it atop, securely, using dowels. You can still place this unit atop the shorter-width unit (instructions indicate that each unit should be attached to the wall and that units should not be stacked higher than 72 inches...an odd number given that each one is 31 inches high--62 inches if on top of each other) and it will not wobble but there will be a slight overlap. The quality on these units has always varied. Holes for screws are often too small and have to be worked to widen them (carefully so you don't split the laminate) when you attach the permanent top and bottom shelves. Additionally the holes on the interior sides are often slimmer than they need to be to accommodate the pegs that hold the shelves. And you need to check carefully, BEFORE you start assembly, that you have all the pieces listed on the instruction sheet. You should also check to see that you have correctly lined up the shelf top and bottom when you afix them to the sides. (Trust me when I tell you it's easier than you think to either have the wrong shelf or to place improperly.) And never throw the box out without checking to be sure you've removed the very slim paper backing for the shelf unit. It does not slide out with the other pieces when you tip the box over to empty it out. It's very easy, as some have done, to toss it out and think it hasn't been sent. The kit comes with 14 nails for you to use in fastening the paper back (the company really should offer a back of the same material as the other pieces. It would be worth a few dollars more.) but you will probably need more if you want it to firmly adhere to the sides and top without gaps. So get some extra nails of this kind, which many of us already have around the house. The key is securing the four corners properly first before you begin to put nails into the paper back along the long sides and across the top and bottom shelves. You have to be careful that all four corners line up properly or you will end up with too little of the backing as needed to secure the nails properly. And as others have noted you have to carefully place the nails so that they go thru the paper back but also into the wooden/grainy part but NOT close to the laminate facing. Otherwise, you'll split the laminate when you pound the nails in. Use a lightweight hammer and go slowly. I've never tried to use a staple gun, but I suspect if you have one and you're good with it in terms of placement, that it might be an easier way to secure this back.
Very sturdy and easy to assemble
By Susan Ross - Reviewed in the United States on April 1, 2025
Verified Amazon Purchase
I have so many of these. I designed a closet with these. They are sturdy, easy to assemble and a great size.
Beautiful, sturdy shelves for my big large desk!
By Whut - Reviewed in the United States on July 13, 2016
Verified Amazon Purchase
Much higher quality than I believed I would get. The fake wood grain design is MUCH more beautiful, and the materials used seem much more sturdy than what I thought I was going to get when I ordered. I'm currently using them as a place for my analog speaker set to live along with my amp which is plugged into my computer. There's still lots of space which I'm sure will somehow collect random junk when I don't know where to put things. The shelving units are not that heavy. Also, the shelves fit VERY tightly and snug which is an extreme plus. I was worrying about having funky, loose & floppy shelves until I saw the greatness of these. You can also fit wires down behind the shelves if you have, say, something on the bottom that needs to be connected to the top shelf (like my amp & the speaker I have in the upper shelf). YOU CANNOT however pass wires through the back, top, or bottom of the unit without making a permanent hole in the cardboard backing. Setup was pretty easy, just need a normal hand operated screw driver and not punch a hole in the cheap cardboard backing when hammering its thin nails in. Also, when I ordered these I read someone else's review that mentioned that the screws should have been inset because they came with caps to hide them, but they didn't work. Yeah, they came with caps to hide the screws, but actually they DO work. You just plug the caps into the Philips screw hole on each screw and they become invisible. There's also 2 plugs that go on top for when you aren't stacking the units. I think that reviewer probably got confused with those pieces. I put rubber stoppers on the bottom of the shelving units so they wouldn't slide easily. It definitely may be something you want to do if you may not always have heavy things on it and you want it to stay right in place. Attached are pictures of my current setup. DO NOT look at my photos for colors. The color is not accurate on this photo because it was taken at night in a poorly lit room.
Perfect for first-time apartments, even if the construction is cheap
By Caitlin B - Reviewed in the United States on October 6, 2016
Verified Amazon Purchase
I was looking for something to use as a nightstand, and I only had about 13 inches to work with. This shelf is perfect! Well, not *perfect*, but it fits where I need it to go, was relatively simple to put together, and looks pretty nice. Its not the sturdiest, but I'm not planning on putting anything heavy on top (and part of the slight wobble is the fact that my floors are old and uneven), aside from maybe a small lamp. I only put 2 drawers in because I wanted to use the top section to put books and stuff, but I got the drawers that another reviewer mentioned (by Winsome), and they fit great! You could definitely fit 3 of these if you wanted. The construction of these shelves was...sub-par. There was a big chip out of one corner of one of the side pieces, and there were some scratches and stuff, but honestly that's to be expected when you're buying something like this in this price range. The chip didn't affect the stability of the shelves, and I was able to hide it by putting that shelf on the far side of the bed where it couldn't be seen. I also chose not to put the back on. I don't have a hammer (and even if I did, I don't really want to annoy my neighbors with hammering sounds, or smash my thumb by accident), and the back seems kind of unnecessary anyway, at least for my purposes. To keep the shelves from sliding around, I rolled up pieces of tape and put them on the little plastic brackets. Works like a charm, and you can't see it unless you lay down and look up at the underside of the shelves (even then it's not very noticeable). Not the most elegant solution, but hey, it gets the job done. I also didn't anchor these to the wall, because the plaster in my apartment is pretty weak, and I don't want to cause any damage. I'm going to load the bottoms with heavier stuff (like books) to help keep the shelves stable, and I'm sure it'll work out fine. Bottom line: if you get these shelves, go into it with low expectations, and you won't be disappointed! For the price, these shelves are great, easy to put together, and look pretty nice, all things considered. If you're looking for shelves that will become family heirlooms passed down from generation to generation, get different shelves. But if you just want some basic shelves to use as closet storage, or night stands, or end tables, these are great!
Returned
By RG - Reviewed in the United States on September 16, 2024
Verified Amazon Purchase
I returned this because I was looking for a solid cube piece of furniture that would of fit into a narrow space. This was listed under that search. The picture makes it look like a cube piece of furniture. The product description only said 12 inches which sounded like a cube. They did not list any other measurements. I was was expecting something taller. The product said it was heavy so I left instructions for my mail carrier to ask us for help getting it to our door. It was not that heavy. It was short. The total dimensions listed on the box were: 12.13" width X 11.63" depth X 31.5" height. The total shelf height would of been abput 10" each if divided equally. So because it would not of met my needs, I decided to return it.
Show more reviews