Back to Amazon.com
customer reviews
3,073
4.3 out of 5 stars

Westbend 54159 Coffee Percolator

$29.99
$70 57% off Reference Price
Condition: New
Sold out Back to product details

Top positive review
1 people found this helpful
Love It!
By Steve on Reviewed in the United States on March 29, 2025
Love this percolator coffeemaker! Paired with an auto timer I purchased separately...Brews delicious coffee when it's needed. We have very hard water, that eats the auto-drip coffeemakers. This model has performed flawlessly form day one! We use Kroger branded regular coffee, just follow included instructions...you'll be impressed! Love the auto keep warm after brewing.
Top critical review
12 people found this helpful
Plastic handle leaks, and pot not that well made
By Tim on Reviewed in the United States on March 26, 2012
I really tried to research percolators as much as I could, and decided to give this West Bend a try. It arrived quickly and was packed well. I am replacing a Faberware that quit working due to thermostat problems similar to what everyone else has said about Faberware. Compared to the Faberware, the West Bend is not constructed as well. The gauge of the metal is thinner on the West Bend, and overall it seems more cheaply made. Of course it only cost $38, so maybe it's just a case of you get what you pay for? The metal isn't polished quite as nicely either. However, appearance aside, the pot does seem to brew OK but as others have mentioned the clear plastic cap leaks and you have to wipe it up. You have to wrap a cloth or paper towel around the top handle for each batch. There is no seal between the handle and the cap and clearly it needs one. Also, so far the coffee isn't very strong for the amount of grounds I'm using. I have tried it with a paper filter and without, and each way the coffee seems to back up and not drain through quickly enough and ends up spilling over the top which means the water isn't picking up the flavor and strength as much as it should. When the cycle is complete, which is about 1 min/cup as advertised, the coffee remains in the basket a long time. In fact, a couple of times I had to use a spoon to help move the grounds around to get the remaining coffee in the basket to drain through after waiting 10 minutes after the cycle stopped. This is with regular grind coffee! It seems to me that there are not enough drain holes in the basket. Back in earlier days of more high quality percolators, some of them had a fine mesh in the baskets rather than just a few punched holes. I haven't been able to try it since I was able to return the Faberware, but what might work with this West Bend unit is to use the basket and basket top from the Faberware 12 cup unit inside the West Bend. Not sure it fits, but if it does that might work well. The Faberware parts are thicker gauge and nicer overall, and it seemed to drain the coffee better from the basket. That is just speculation for others think have a Faberware laying around... I'll try this pot few more days and possibly return it to Amazon if things don't improve...

Sort by:
Filter by:
Love It!
By Steve - Reviewed in the United States on March 29, 2025
Verified Amazon Purchase
Love this percolator coffeemaker! Paired with an auto timer I purchased separately...Brews delicious coffee when it's needed. We have very hard water, that eats the auto-drip coffeemakers. This model has performed flawlessly form day one! We use Kroger branded regular coffee, just follow included instructions...you'll be impressed! Love the auto keep warm after brewing.
I'll Never Go Back to Drip-Brewing
By Kalaab M. Pickering - Reviewed in the United States on June 14, 2013
Verified Amazon Purchase
I bought this unit as a replacement for a Mr. Coffee drip-brew that died after 5 months. This was a very disappointing turn of events because I expected a lot more out of that coffee maker. I brew coffee daily, but coffee makers should be able to last longer than 5 months. Anyway, I decided to switch to a percolator because I decided the bells and whistles of the modern drip-brew didn't really do me that much good and the quality of the coffee was only decent at best. I originally ordered a percolator made by Presto, but the shipping was so slow I cancelled the order and opted for this West Bend model, which was Amazon Prime-Eligible and arrived in two days. I usually use a dark roast (French or Italian roast) with distilled water (the tap water where I live has a lot of lime in it). The coffee out of this percolator is fantastic. It's quick to brew and easy to use. The best feature of this percolator is something very simple, the thermostat. This percolator brews at the perfect temperature, and when it's done it'll leave the coffee at a perfect temperature, about 200 degrees. Also, there is no auto-shutoff, so you can expect your coffee to be at a perfect temperature until you unplug the percolator. This is really great to me because my previous maker shut off after two hours, but the coffee wasn't hot enough to enjoy until it had been sitting on the burner for about 40 minutes. That meant I had to slug down all the coffee in the remaining time or turn the burner back on, which was a slight pain in the neck. I pace myself, but I drink coffee from 8:00 AM to 8:00 PM, so I like it hot and ready when I want a cup. Some reviewers have complained that this percolator has a plastic dome rather than glass, but I don't really think that's a big concern. Firstly, this percolator is very affordable, so you have to expect cheaper materials. Second, considering the era in which it is manufactured, it's not at all unexpected that a manufacturer would use cheaper materials without compromising quality. Some percolators out there don't even have a clear plastic dome, so being able to watch it percolate is kind of a cool treat. The overall fit and finish of the percolator is quite nice, especially considering its price. If you're a coffee drinker that depends on timers, auto-shutoffs, pre-ground beans, built-in clocks, and other amenities, this might not be the maker for you. However, if you are enthusiastic about the flavor and quality of your coffee, percolators in general are a great choice, and this percolator specifically is a cheap and easy way to try it out. The quality of the coffee that comes out of this percolator is amazing. This is my first percolator, and I just figured bitterness and harsh flavor were something that you just had to expect from some blends, but this device proved me completely wrong. For the first time, I brewed a strong French roast and got a rich, brown, flavorful cup of coffee without any bitterness. It was almost off-putting because it didn't taste anything like what I was used to, so it took a bit to appreciate the pureness of the brew from this machine. I highly recommend this percolator.
makes good coffee. pour spout is right on. No drips
By Tricia Green - Reviewed in the United States on March 19, 2025
Verified Amazon Purchase
we are very satisfied with our new electric west bend percolator coffee maker. the only thing that i thought was kind of odd about it is that it is pretty noisy. But that is certainly something that is not going to take away from the good coffee that it makes. we use regular course ground coffee and it brews a richer flavored coffee that we didn't even know we were missing until we started using this coffee pot. The drip coffee maker that we have used for many years just doesn't stand up. the fact that it takes up less space is also a plus. over all it deserves the 5 stars that we gave it. I want to add another point...we have hard water and the drip coffee maker had to be replaced about every 3 months. so I always bought a cheaper model due to that problem. But with this coffee maker I can run a brush through the stem, clean the inside and clean it thoroughly and not have to replace it every months. that is going to save us about 130.00 a year in coffee pots. I know thats not a lot in the whole picture of everything but it certainly is going to be a lot more convenient.
Great coffee pot so far.
By Mary - Reviewed in the United States on April 12, 2024
Verified Amazon Purchase
This is a good percolator so far. West Bend has been around for a long time. No need for a filter although there are a few grounds on the bottom of the pot. Brews fast and delivers a great tasting, hot cup of coffee. I gave it four starts due to the length of time it took to get here. When I ordered it it stated five days. A few days later I was told it was delayed. Finally nine days later it arrived. Too long when you are without a coffee pot.
Love My Westbend Percolator!
By Amazon Customer - Reviewed in the United States on November 13, 2020
Verified Amazon Purchase
After our last 'modern' brewer became possessed - the grinder (which hadn't worked at all in quite a while) on the stupid thing would start up on its own - I decided to go back to a good old reliable percolator. After much thought, I decided on this one. Glad I did! This is a very nice percolator and it does everything I expected. I also love the fact that it doesn't take up half my counter space like the fancy new drip machines that don't last long anymore. I read all the reviews and took some advice from other reviewers (like making sure the basket is wet before putting the filter in, especially if using finer (drip grind) ground coffee - genius!) I'm using regular basket filters ... just take a little stack, fold in half, make a snip; fold in half the other way, make another snip; now you have a filter with a 'hole' in it to fit over the stem in the basket. A couple of reviewers said they have had problems with coffee dripping from the clear knob on the top. (The clear knob is plastic, by the way ... but what else can you expect in today's throw-away world?) Mine has had maybe one drip on a couple of occasions, but no big deal. I just make sure the lid is securely fitted onto the pot and haven't had a problem since. Since this percolator does not come with a timer on it, I plug it into an outlet timer, and taa-daa! Freshly brewed coffee when I wake up! It smells wonderful as it brews and I can't help it, I love the percolating sound and watching it perk (fond childhood memories). The coffee is HOT and tastes so much fresher than drip. It stays hot until it shuts off (if empty) or you unplug it - without that hot plate burned taste to it (and I've left it on for 3-4 hours...). There are only 2 negative things I can say about this pot: 1- it seems kind of loud, but you get used to it pretty quickly, and I rather expected it for this kind of brewing process; and 2 - unless you grind your own beans (or can grind them at the store), it is difficult to find "percolator grind" coffee, which is coarser than drip grind. But the grind is not the percolator's fault! If using a drip grind, make sure you use a filter! I have made both grinds with and without filters and there will be a little bit of grind residue without a filter with the percolator grind. Drip grind without a filter leaves a LOT of grounds residue ... but it's no big deal to me, I just close my eyes, enjoy the aroma and taste, look out at all my trees and remember the good old days of camping and coffee by the fire :) Overall, I'm very happy with the purchase and would buy it again.
Happy with this purchase
By Amazon Customer - Reviewed in the United States on February 6, 2025
Verified Amazon Purchase
I was tired of having lukewarm coffee from our current coffee maker. I also did not want a keurig coffee maker because I have never had a good cup of coffee any of the times that I have used them. I decided to go "old school" and selected this percolator based on reviews and it's more vintage look. So far, I love it. The coffee stays hot, tastes better, and I love the clear knob so that I can see the coffee percolating. It also makes the coffee much more quickly. It does take a little more time to clean, but it's worth it.
Never de-scale or run out of filters again, plus better tasting coffee
By jayemare - Reviewed in the United States on February 27, 2025
Verified Amazon Purchase
I absolutely love this thing. Follow the directions and wet the basket before adding grounds, and you will have no more residual grounds as a drip coffee maker that gets full of scale. Paper filters strip flavorful oils from coffee. This percolator with stainless steel basket does not, resulting in better coffee. Plus never wake up to find you ran out of filters, because none required so better for you and better for environment. Added bonus, coffee does not go stale. Coffee remaining from the day prior can be reheated without the bitter taste of stale coffee that has oxidized in a drip coffee craft. Less wasted coffee! Because there is no complicated plumbing, there is nothing to collect scale build up. Never using drip makers again. Been using this percolator daily for going on 4 years now.
The percolator for those who loved the original mid-century versions
By A. D. Hill - Reviewed in the United States on January 27, 2012
Verified Amazon Purchase
I consider myself knowledgeable about percolators because I have been using vintage models for the past six years. Percolators from the 1950s and 60s were a highly polished chrome and sleek in design. I've gone through three of them prior to finally buying a new one. I settled on this model and definitely made the right choice. Here is why I love percolators and how this model ranks: 1) Great-tasting coffee. I've always preferred the taste of percolated coffee. The model doesn't have settings for brew strength like some of the vintage models but the manufacturer's setting is perfect for my taste. 2) Good-looking compared to auto-drip. This model is OK but not as shiny and "mod" in design as the originals, but it's attractive. 3) No need to spend money on filters. No worries about dioxin from paper filters or paper affecting taste. Less waste. Applies here! 4) Pleasant sounding WHOOSH!...WHOOSH! as the coffee heats up and can be seen in the clear bubble top. Applies here except that West Bend has a plastic bubble top instead of glass. That's better in one way because you don't have to worry about breaking it, but I prefer to not have my hot coffee come in contact with plastic. Not a big deal. 5) You can place the percolator filled with hot coffee on a table unlike a glass pot from a auto-drip maker so that if you are entertaining or want to bring the "pot" of coffee with you, simply unplug then remove the plug from the percolator. This model does just that! 6) No splashing or spilling when you pour coffee! The spout on this percolator is precision-perfect. Whenever I poured from an auto-drip carafe it almost always spilled a little no matter how carefully I poured. Keep in mind that you can't submerge a percolator in water. I recommend using filtered water for better tasting coffee and to prolong the life of your percolator. I wash mine by rinsing it out with hot water and I Windex the outside as needed. I've not had a problem with build-up. The inside is stainless so it rinses very well. I'm very happy with my purchase.
Fantastic!
By Joseph Passarella - Reviewed in the United States on April 2, 2025
Verified Amazon Purchase
I'll NEVER go back to a drip coffee maker. Half the counter space. Sleek and modern look. And better (also hotter) coffee than a drip machine. Here's the added perk - it takes about the same time to brew as a drip maker does.
Love it
By Frogg1969 - Reviewed in the United States on March 20, 2025
Verified Amazon Purchase
Perfect size easy to use
Show more reviews