Back to Amazon.com
customer reviews
13,914
4.2 out of 5 stars

Gotham Steel Sandwich Maker

$11.99
$19.99 40% off Reference Price
Condition: New
Size: Double sandwich
Sold out Back to product details

Top positive review
3 people found this helpful
Would buy again
By Krista on Reviewed in the United States on May 14, 2025
Works great! sometimes the bread is too big and you have to cut it down but presses the bread together. Quick heat up and easy to use! removable plates for easy clean up and easy to store too. Build quality is solid and its a good price for the quality!
Top critical review
5 people found this helpful
Terrible Quality – Stopped Working & Not Worth It
By Satyajit Chowdhury on Reviewed in the United States on February 7, 2025
I regret buying this Gotham Steel Panini Press—it’s a complete waste of money. After just a few uses, it stopped heating properly and now won’t even turn on. The build quality feels cheap, and the nonstick coating started peeling way too soon. The cut edges feature is useless, as it doesn’t cut the sandwiches cleanly, just smashes them unevenly. Plus, the indicator light is unreliable—sometimes it stays on, sometimes it doesn’t, making it hard to tell if it's even working. This product is not durable and poorly designed. I expected much better from Gotham Steel, but this was a total letdown. Save your money and get a better-quality sandwich press instead!

Sort by:
Filter by:
Would buy again
By Krista - Reviewed in the United States on May 14, 2025
Verified Amazon Purchase
Works great! sometimes the bread is too big and you have to cut it down but presses the bread together. Quick heat up and easy to use! removable plates for easy clean up and easy to store too. Build quality is solid and its a good price for the quality!
Thanks
By PauloBerce - Reviewed in the United States on June 7, 2025
Verified Amazon Purchase
Good Machine
Fits my need
By Marie white - Reviewed in the United States on April 6, 2025
Verified Amazon Purchase
I like it, cant do big bread or sandwich. Overall it good
Great sandwich press.
By Jim - Reviewed in the United States on June 2, 2025
Verified Amazon Purchase
Works great, love the non-stick!
Sandwhich Press
By Toni H Steward - Reviewed in the United States on May 29, 2025
Verified Amazon Purchase
Perfect gave as a gift.
Terrible Quality – Stopped Working & Not Worth It
By Satyajit Chowdhury - Reviewed in the United States on February 7, 2025
Verified Amazon Purchase
I regret buying this Gotham Steel Panini Press—it’s a complete waste of money. After just a few uses, it stopped heating properly and now won’t even turn on. The build quality feels cheap, and the nonstick coating started peeling way too soon. The cut edges feature is useless, as it doesn’t cut the sandwiches cleanly, just smashes them unevenly. Plus, the indicator light is unreliable—sometimes it stays on, sometimes it doesn’t, making it hard to tell if it's even working. This product is not durable and poorly designed. I expected much better from Gotham Steel, but this was a total letdown. Save your money and get a better-quality sandwich press instead!
Love it. Cleaning it, not so much.
By bmix18 - Reviewed in the United States on October 23, 2023
Verified Amazon Purchase
I was looking for a sandwich press with a safe cooking surface, and discovered this press. Something for a fun snack here or there. I hadn't had a grilled cheese since I was in my teens and have been wanting to try one that's been made on a press like this. Let me say, this made the best grilled cheese I've ever had. Way better than how I remember making them in a frying pan on the stove, and a lot quicker. Both sides toasted nicely, for me, in just 4 minutes(Tried 5 and a little to burnt for my liking. I believe recipe included says 5 minutes for a grilled cheese). Only issue with the press is cleaning it. The cooking surface is easy to clean, but whatever may leak out of the sandwich onto the exterior plastic is hard to clean off. When I bought it, I expected the cooking surface to be removable for cleaning/rinsing. Nope, regardless, I highly recommend this press. A lot of fun.
Quality
By Anita Grant - Reviewed in the United States on May 5, 2025
Verified Amazon Purchase
Love it n easy to use
Good value
By Good product, works great, used a few times now and will buy another for the front of my house 👍 - Reviewed in the United States on March 5, 2025
Verified Amazon Purchase
Works great but did break the third time I used it
Quick and easy dinner
By Betty Scapin - Reviewed in the United States on April 3, 2025
Verified Amazon Purchase
This is a perfect thing to cook dinner for your family any night. Make a grilled cheese to go with some soup. Or you can make a Panini, or you can make Pizza pockets with it. But when you're done, it's easy to clean up.
Show more reviews