Back to Amazon.com
customer reviews
13,942
4.2 out of 5 stars

Gotham Steel Sandwich Maker

$11.99
$19.99 40% off Reference Price
Condition: New
Size: Double sandwich
Sold out Back to product details

Top positive review
1 people found this helpful
Game Changer for Grilled Cheese Lovers
By Duke of Westfall St on Reviewed in the United States on June 19, 2025
This GOTHAM STEEL Sandwich Maker is an absolute life saver! It’s incredibly easy to use—plug it in, load up your sandwiches, and a few minutes later you’ve got perfectly toasted, melty goodness with those classic grill lines. My kids love it and honestly won’t settle for a pan-grilled cheese anymore! Cleanup is basically non-existent thanks to the ultra nonstick copper surface. The easy-cut edges and indicator lights make the whole process foolproof. It’s compact, efficient, and seriously a game changer for busy mornings or quick lunches. Highly recommend!
Top critical review
28 people found this helpful
Save your money
By Bella on Reviewed in the United States on September 6, 2022
I was excited to start using this product. I followed the directions to clean the surface before using. I made my husband & I basic Grilled Cheese Sandwiches. Being careful not to put too much cheese, being I didn’t know how it will turn out. I followed the directions provided how to make the Grilled Cheese. First issue, was the latch was hard to align & clip closed. Second, I noticed cheese oozing from the sides & from the back all over the hinges & heating cable. Third, the melted cheese made it hard to open the top to get the sandwiches out. It finally opened, there was cheese all over. I took the 2 sandwiches out and wiped the plates to prepare for the next 2 sandwiches. There was cheese stuck to the plastic frame, couldn’t get the cheese off easily. Put the final 2 sandwiches in, same amount of cheese as the first two. The same thing happened, cheese oozing out of the sides & out of the back. Even though I cleaned the plates before use, there was a strange taste to the sandwiches. Needless to say neither my husband or I were happy with the Gotham Steel Sandwich Maker. I would hate to see what a mess there would be if we were making any other recipes in the booklet. One positive note, it did do a good job browning the bread. Because we used the item, we didn’t think we could return it & threw it away. Our advice is don’t waste your money.

Sort by:
Filter by:
By -
Verified Amazon Purchase
Vine Customer Review of Free Product
Sorry, no reviews match your current selections.
Try clearing or changing some filters.Show all reviews
Show more reviews


people found this helpful
By -
Verified Amazon Purchase
Vine Customer Review of Free Product